Here are the final line-ups of each 2004 team.
| Idgits Steve Loring Scott Arnold Mike Davis Dave Dygert Chris Will Les Moore |
| TITTS Scott Nice Tom Bowman Mark Bixler Pierre Gendreaux Chris Fraley |
| Where's Wilbur Steve Panko Tom Vilardo Max Hamilton Curt Robinson Paul Pfeiffer |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| 2 And Out Todd Heywood Matt Gomon Jeff Sullivan Tom Pohlman Kelly O'Neill |
| Jimmi Flash Greg Berger Chris Berger Scott Nice Rob Cafera Jeff Lopper |
| 4 Men & A Baby Gene Salyer Tommy Wright Mike Parise Jeff Popp Chad Hilliker |
| Visitors |
| The Leaksters Jeff Iles Joe Worthington Jeff Cooper John Gerth Toby Stoller |
| It Takes Two Lonnie Sneed Mike Sauer Wayne Seibert Richard Seibert Frank Sullivan |
| Kings Kids Mike King Dave Bolender Jon Witt Shawn Liller Mike Fulkerson |
| 4 Jerks & A Squirt Chris Clark Chris Kamphaus Tim Scanlon Eric Vonbausch Tony Weaver |
| Maybe Bush Jason Cooper Ben Clark Sean Luley Casey Budd Curtis Penick |
| Jerry's Kids Jerry Combs Walt Carver Tom Geyer Brady Greene Tony Galeo |
| Teams |
The Leaky Classic
 |  |  |  |